Brown Butter Seared Scallops

These brown butter seared scallops are built on a simple technique: dry-packed sea scallops (they'll almost always start frozen - I'll show you how to thaw), a hot stainless steel pan, and enough patience to leave them alone for three and a half minutes. The result is a deep golden crust and a quick pan sauce of brown butter, lemon, and basil that comes together while the scallops rest.

If you're a scallop fan, my Air Fryer Scallops with Crispy Panko Crust are worth bookmarking for a completely different texture. And if you're looking for a full dinner plan, Baked Scallops with Crispy Panko Breadcrumbs is another weeknight option that delivers.

Ingredients for Seared Scallops :

Before we get to the step by step instructions, a few notes about the ingredients (I included the ingredients for my charred corn grits, which is how I serve these scallops - but that is optional!):

1 pound sea scallops - dry-packed, thawed. Large or jumbo size gives you the best window for developing a crust without overcooking the center. More on dry-packed below.

Butter + olive oil. We use the oil for the first side sear, then add butter to baste and build a simple pan sauce.

Juice of half a lemon, plus wedges for serving.

Fresh basil, kosher salt and black pepper.

Full measurements and instructions in the recipe card below.

Why Dry-Packed Scallops Make the Difference

Not all frozen scallops are the same. Wet-packed scallops are treated with a solution that causes them to absorb and retain water. That water releases into the pan as soon as the scallop hits the heat, which drops the pan temperature and steams the exterior before a crust can form. So you end up with a pale surface, which is the opposite of what you want.

Dry-packed scallops contain no additives. They release almost no water in the pan, which means the surface stays dry long enough to caramelize. It's the single biggest variable in getting a proper sear.

To spot the difference: wet-packed scallops tend to look very white and almost glossy in the package. Dry-packed are more ivory or pale beige with a drier appearance. On the label, look for "dry" or "dry-packed." If you see "treated with sodium tripolyphosphate" or "STP," those are wet-packed.

Sizzlefish is my go-to source for dry-packed sea scallops - they ship directly to your door and the quality is consistently excellent. I used them for both this recipe and my Air Fryer Scallops.

Why This Recipe Works

The first side is where the work happens. Three to three and a half minutes in a hot pan, untouched. That's what builds the crust. Moving the scallops before they're ready tears the sear and costs you the browned bits that become your pan sauce.

I've used cast iron, nonstick and stainless steel in testing these scallops, and stainless steel gave the most consistent result. Cast iron would be my second choice. Nonstick will get the scallops cooked, but produces a lighter sear and less fond to work with in making the sauce.

The second side only needs a minute, with butter and basting. Then the scallops come off the heat and the sauce takes two minutes in the same pan. The whole cook is under 10 minutes once everything is prepped.

The Best Way to Thaw Frozen Scallops

In the refrigerator (preferred): Place sealed scallops in the fridge 24 hours before you plan to cook. Slow, even thaw with no quality loss.

In cold water (faster): Keep scallops in sealed packaging and submerge in a bowl of cold water for 20 to 30 minutes. Don't use warm water - it starts cooking the exterior before the inside has thawed.

Once thawed, pat the scallops very dry with paper towels. Any surface moisture left on the scallop will steam in the pan before it can sear.

How to make brown butter seared scallops:

Step 1: Prep scallops

Pat thawed scallops very dry with paper towels. Check the side of each scallop for the adductor muscle - a small, tough tag that pulls away easily. Remove it if present. Season both sides with salt and pepper.

Step 2: Sear the scallops

Heat a stainless steel skillet over medium-high heat until hot. Add oil. When the oil shimmers, add the scallops in a single layer, presentation side down. Sear without moving for 3 to 3.5 minutes, until a deep golden-brown crust has formed on the bottom.

Flip, reduce heat to medium, then add 3 tablespoons of butter to the pan. Baste for 1 minute, then remove scallops to a plate and tent loosely with foil.

Step 3: Make pan sauce

Return the pan to medium heat. Squeeze in the lemon juice, add last tablespoon of butter and scrape up any browned bits from the bottom. Swirl gently. Taste and adjust seasoning. Tear in the basil.

Step 4: Serve

Spoon the sauce over the scallops and serve immediately with extra lemon wedges.

How do you know when scallops are done?

Pull them at 120°F. Carryover heat will take them to 130 to 135°F by the time they reach the plate. Without a thermometer, look for a center that's just opaque, no longer translucent. A properly cooked scallop has a little give when pressed - firm, but not rubbery. Firm and bouncy means overcooked.

Can you cook scallops straight from frozen?

You can, but the results aren't worth it. Ice crystals melt faster than the surface can dry out, which floods the pan with moisture and prevents a sear. Thaw first, pat dry, then cook. The extra step makes the whole recipe.

What pan is best for searing scallops?

Stainless steel is the first choice. It gets very hot, holds that heat when cold scallops hit the surface, and gives you a proper fond for the sauce. Cast iron is my second choice. Nonstick works in a pinch but produces a lighter sear and less fond, so your sauce suffers.

How do you store leftover seared scallops?

Transfer to an airtight container and refrigerate for up to two days. Reheat gently in a skillet over low heat with a little butter, just until warmed through. Once cooked, don't refreeze.

Print